The Perfect Game Of Thrones & Harry Potter Replacement Has Been In Development Hell For 10 Years

The Perfect Game Of Thrones & Harry Potter Replacement Has Been In Development Hell For 10 Years


  • The Kingkiller Chronicle combines parts of each Sport of Thrones and Harry Potter, making it a really perfect substitute for followers of each fantasy franchises.
  • The difference of The Kingkiller Chronicle has confronted a number of setbacks and struggles since being optioned in 2013. There are at present no agency updates on its progress.
  • One potential downside with adapting The Kingkiller Chronicle is that the story stays unfinished, with the third and closing guide but to be launched.

There’s one fantasy guide that will be a really perfect film or TV present substitute for each Sport of Thrones and Harry Potter, nevertheless it’s been caught in growth since 2013. The recognition of Sport of Thrones and Harry Potter has led to a slew of flicks and reveals aiming to capitalize on that success, although few have fairly managed to succeed in the identical heights they did. Each have even launched their very own prequels – Home of the Dragon and Improbable Beasts – equally seeking to try to construct on their massive fanbases (although the latter, at the least, did not go to plan).

Though there are extra upcoming Sport of Thrones spinoffs, in addition to Max growing a Harry Potter remake TV present, there stays a eager curiosity in networks and studios discovering their very own slice of fantasy motion (whether or not that is Netflix with The Witcher and Shadow and Bone, Disney with Percy Jackson, or Amazon with The Wheel of Time and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Energy). One story that in principle ought to work to mix a number of the better of each worlds is Patrick Rothfuss’ The Kingkiller Chronicle, which tells the story of Kvothe and the way he turned the infamous “kingkiller”. Nevertheless, an adaptation has by no means come to fruition.

How The Kingkiller Chronicle Brilliantly Combines Sport Of Thrones & Harry Potter

The 2 Kingkiller Chronicle books thus far function a really perfect mixture of Sport of Thrones (or at the least, A Track of Ice and Fireplace) and Harry Potter. In fact, the books have their very own distinctive parts and are certainly not carbon copies or ripoffs, however there are clear similarities between the completely different fantasy tales that make it excellent as a substitute that sits someplace between the 2 (it is extra excessive fantasy than Harry Potter, however not fairly as darkish as Sport of Thrones). It has core parts of each, and does them extraordinarily properly in a method that ought to not solely lend itself to an adaptation, however enchantment to followers of each, with out being too same-y.

The Kingkiller Chronicle‘s location, the fictional Temerant, has some parallels to Westeros, particularly in how wealthy and detailed it’s: this can be a sprawling world with many extremely fleshed-out cultures, languages, guidelines, and a way of marvel, with loads of variation and invention, and a transparent sense of this being lived-in. It is a setting filled with magic and music, to not point out somewhat little bit of homicide, and Rothfuss’ prose and elegance is influenced by George R.R. Martin. The Kingkiller Chronicle is a bit more singular in its character focus, however the way in which a film or TV present may deliver Temerant to life and discover it will be much like what Sport of Thrones did with Westeros.

The Kingkiller Chronicle‘s similarities to Harry Potter are even clearer. It is a story a few younger boy (Kvothe/Harry Potter) whose mother and father are killed by a robust villain, who then goes on to be taught magic at college (or College), and can have an ideal many adventures and battles exterior that setting, gaining nice renown, whereas additionally scuffling with the day-to-day lifetime of it. It is concerning the friendships he makes, and the rivalries too, be that with a privileged bully (Ambrose/Draco Malfoy) or the extraordinarily imply instructor who takes an immense dislike to the hero (Hemme/Snape).

What’s Going On With The Kingkiller Chronicle Film & TV Present?

Kingkiller Chronicle The Lightning Tree

The Kingkiller Chronicle was first optioned for a TV adaptation by twentieth Century Fox again in 2013, two years after the second guide within the sequence, The Smart Man’s Concern, had been launched. Sadly, there was no motion on the present, and the rights expired in 2015. Rothfuss then made a cope with Lionsgate [via], with bold plans to adapt the principle books right into a film, but additionally making a TV present and online game set on the earth alongside it. Lin-Manuel Miranda was introduced onboard to compose music for the present, however once more manufacturing did not actually get going.

In late 2017, Showtime was growing the sequence, however that additionally did not progress and Lionsgate began purchasing it round once more by 2019. In the meantime, Sam Raimi was employed to direct the Kingkiller Chronicle film in 2018, however that by no means got here to fruition both. Miranda informed Selection in 2022 that he was not concerned and that they “by no means cracked it,” and the struggles seemingly lie within the books’ construction. Since they’re informed in a Russian Doll type format, with a story-within-a-story, then it is clearly proving tough to be able to get proper. There have been no agency updates since then, and it would not seem to be there will be motion anytime quickly.

The Kingkiller Chronicle Adaptation Has 1 Drawback (Which Damage Sport Of Thrones)

Cover art for Patrick Rothfuss's novels The Name of the Wind and The Wise Man's Fear.

Maybe one other a part of the issue with adapting The Kingkiller Chronicle is that the story stays unfinished, and there is been an extended anticipate the third and closing guide within the trilogy. The Title of the Wind was launched in 2007, and The Smart Man’s Concern got here out 4 years later. 12 years on, and Rothfuss’ deliberate third guide, The Doorways of Stone, has but to materialize. Much like The Winds of Winter, there have been a number of delays and struggles with writing the novel, and once more there would not appear to be a launch date on the horizon.

Associated: Why The Doorways Of Stone Is Taking So Lengthy – third Kingkiller Chronicle Guide Delay Defined

A Track of Ice and Fireplace being unfinished induced issues for Sport of Thrones‘ ending. Whereas the present was acclaimed whereas adapting Martin’s books, it began to battle extra when it not had that blueprint to work from, and lots of the issues with Sport of Thrones season 8 will be attributed to a scarcity of supply materials. It is doable that’s impacting a Kingkiller Chronicle adaptation, not solely when it comes to making it tougher to develop the story for a film or present, but additionally out of concern from struggling an identical backlash. The Kingkiller Chronicle completely deserves a film or TV adaptation, however its followers are going to have to attend some time but.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here