Supergirl is about to return to the massive display by way of The Flash, however there are already plans for her in James Gunn’s rebooted DC Universe slate. The upcoming Supergirl: Girl of Tomorrow would be the Maid of Would possibly’s first solo film for the reason that Eighties, and it additionally adapts a storyline written by Tom King. Although the announcement of the film has seen that e book change into a best-seller, it finally may not be an awesome match for Kara Zor-El on the massive display.
The e book is way too darkish to actually match Kara’s character, which is a recurring problem with a lot of Tom King’s books. A much better supply can be the Sterling Gates/Jamal Igle Supergirl run, which might be the quintessential tackle the character. Flighty and enjoyable whereas nonetheless having tons of gravitas, this run can be a much better affect on the Lady of Metal’s latest film.
Tom King is perhaps a preferred author, however he is additionally a controversial one, particularly relating to main comedian e book characters. He tends to vary characterization for iconic heroes to be able to justify his tales, with stated ideas probably being a nasty match for the characters in query. Such was the case in Supergirl: Girl of Tomorrow, the place Kara Zor-El wasn’t fairly the sunny character that most individuals know her as. As an alternative, she was portrayed as a typically foul-mouthed drunkard who was pitifully mourning the lack of the planet Krypton.
This runs into one other problem of Tom King’s writing, which is that there are particular plot twists taken to be able to add seeming depth or nuance. King undoubtedly has his pet points on this regard, with grief and psychological well being being probably the most distinguished. Unfortunately, using these themes many occasions comes off as extra shallow lip service than something, particularly contemplating how deep the tales appear to suppose they’re. Supergirl’s habits in Girl of Tomorrow matches pretty effectively into this class, particularly given how she’s portrayed within the story.
Selecting this story for her first solo film since 1984 is kind of baffling, particularly contemplating a number of the tone criticisms for the film appearances of Henry Cavill’s Superman. Any form of depth will probably be glossed over in favor of one thing extra shallow. That is particularly probably given James Gunn’s phrases regarding this model of Supergirl being “harsher, extra F-ed up.” There have been additionally much better sources to tug from, with one run on the character’s e book standing out above them out.
This runs into one other problem of Tom King’s writing, which is that there are particular plot twists taken to be able to add seeming depth or nuance. King undoubtedly has his pet points on this regard, with grief and psychological well being being probably the most distinguished. Sadly, using these themes many occasions comes off as extra shallow lip service than something, particularly contemplating how deep the tales appear to suppose they’re. Supergirl’s habits in Girl of Tomorrow matches pretty effectively into this class, particularly given how she’s portrayed within the story.
Selecting this story for her first solo film since 1984 is kind of baffling, particularly contemplating a number of the tone criticisms for the film appearances of Henry Cavill’s Superman. Any form of depth will probably be glossed over in favor of one thing extra shallow. That is particularly probably given James Gunn’s phrases regarding this model of Supergirl being “harsher, extra F-ed up.” There have been additionally much better sources to tug from, with one run on the character’s e book standing out above them out.
Jamal Igle’s artwork additionally added a traditional and heroic sense to Supergirl, whereas artwork in earlier and later runs made her both livid or overly sexualized. The artwork in Supergirl: Girl of Tomorrow has the identical high quality, however the writing would not at all times match the aesthetic. This makes it moderately perplexing as to why it was chosen because the supply for the film and never the Gates/Igle run, which rather more precisely embodied what Kara is all about. When the movie lastly exhibits up on the massive display, it might give audiences the improper impression of Superman’s cousin, particularly when it comes her finest tales are like.
Leave a Reply